Ashley Alexander and Molly Little are dressed in Halloween jammies and watching a horror movie. Eventually Ashley realizes that Molly isn't scared. Molly challenges Ashley to name one time she's been scared, and Molly describes a threesome in college with Molly's parents in the room next door.

Molly asks Ashley to remind her of the details, and soon the girls are making out with the movie ignored in the background. Easing Ashley back, Molly kisses her way slowly down the blonde's body. Her fingers get busy between Ashley's thighs as their kisses get deeper and hotter. They're interrupted by the doorbell, much to Ashley's chagrin.

Quinton James is at the door, and he's surprised to learn that the girls aren't dressed to go out. When they invite him in and show him what they were up to, though, Quinton is game to see things to their natural conclusion. He watches from the couch as Ashley and Molly make out, licking and suckling each other's tits. Then they come at Quinton together, freeing his hardon so they can suck him off.

As the trio loses their clothes all together, Quinton finds himself on his back with Molly riding his hardon and Ashley on his face. Then Ashley goes for it in reverse cowgirl while Molly gives Quinton the taste of their combined juices.

Molly gets on her knees next so Quinton can slam back home from behind. He does her in doggy while Molly muffles her moans in Ashley's cooch. Once Quinton has made Ashley moan as she lays on her back, he pulls out to cum on her belly. Quinton assures the girls he's no longer planning to go out, either.