Charlie and Alan are feeling pretty awkward after the previous episode, but their silence is interrupted by Charlie's friend Rose pounding at the window. Charlie answers the door and Rose introduces her friend Kandi. With two hot girls on his doorstep, Charlie's not afraid to invite them in to join Alan. Charlie asks Rose to have a talk with him in the kitchen, so they leave Alan on the couch with Kandi.
In the kitchen, Charlie tells Rose she needs to call before coming over. Meanwhile, Kandi offers to suck Alan's dick to distract him so Rose can seduce Charlie. Alan doesn't have a problem with that, so he pops his fuck stick out and lets Kandi do her worst with her hot little mouth. That escalates to Alan peeling Kandi's thong off so he can hike up her miniskirt and fuck her from behind. He is buried balls deep inside Kandi when Rose and Charlie return to the living room and catch them in the act. The brothers show their competitive side as Alan claims to be a better lover than Charlie. Dropping Rose over the edge of the couch, Charlie prepares to prove Alan wrong much to Rose's delight.
After taking a moment to eat Rose out, Charlie pushes Rose's ass cheeks apart and slides into her twat from behind. Now both girls are getting it doggy style to deep moans all around. The girls then try to see which dick is better to ride. They finish their part in the competition by getting on their backs together on the couch so that Charlie and Alan can pound those fuck holes until they can't hold back another moment. Both guys pull out at the same time to cum on their lady's muff. The girls are both impressed with their personal choice, but Charlie is done with Alan mooching. He tells Alan to pack up his stuff and get out.