Jessie Saint and Eliza Ibarra are high school sweethearts who have been thinking of new ways to spice up their love life. As they enjoy a morning makeout, the girls contemplate bringing a dick into their relationship. That idea doesn't stop them from exploring each other's bodies with their soft hands. Eliza and Jessie take turns sampling each other's breasts. Eventually, Eliza settles back with Jessie between her thighs. Jessie gives her brunette lover's pussy a nice stroking, but Eliza isn't about to let Jessie have all the fun. The girls wind up masturbating each other as they lay side by side in bed, smiling with their contentment.

After cumming, Eliza and Jessie settle on inviting their techie guy friend Seth Gamble over under the pretense that he's going to fix their computer. Settling on the couch, Seth focuses on the computer. He barely realizes that the girls have flanked him until their hands are on him. Seth has a wife, a fact that he tries to mention, but Eliza and Jessire are unmoved. They've decided they want his cock and they're going to get it.

As Eliza explores what it's like to have a dick in her mouth, Jessie takes a taste of Seth's lips. The girls swap spots, and Eliza pulls her shirt up so Seth can suck her nipples. Once they've satisfied their curiosity for what it's like to suck a man off, the girls move on to something a little bit more hardcore.

Eliza is the first to experience what it's like to be filled with man meat. She bounces carefully on Seth's fuck stick as Jessie climbs on top of Seth's face. Eating out one lesbian and fucking the other, it's no surprise that Seth has quickly forgotten that he's married. The girls eventually swap spots so that Jessie can experience the D while Eliza finds out what it feels like to have a man's face buried in her pussy.

On her back on the couch, Eliza welcomes Seth back inside as she pulls Jessie onto her mouth. Muffling her moans in her lover's twat, Eliza is eager to get all that Seth has to give. Meanwhile, Jessie leans forward to use her mouth to lap at Eliza's clit as Eliza is being fucked and to suck Seth off any time he pops out.

When Eliza turns around so that her face is beneath Seth's balls, Jessie turns with her. That puts Jessie on her knees in front of Seth, who is quick to tap that. He delivers a doggy style pussy pounding as Eliza sucks his balls. Since her face is right above Eliza's cooch, Jessie leans in for a pseudo-69.

That's the position that gets Seth to the end of his finish line. He pulls out and cums hard, covering Jessie's ass in cum. Seth's jizz is the final thing the girls have been curious about. Eliza licks it off of Jessie's lap, then leans in so they can snowball their salty treat.